Sports Ethics
An Anthology
1. Auflage November 2002
372 Seiten, Softcover
Wiley & Sons Ltd
ISBN:
978-0-631-21697-1
John Wiley & Sons
The essays in this reader examine philosophical issues such as
sportsmanship, violence, cheating, drug use, racism, sexism, and
gender equity.
* * Examines ethical issues in sports, such as sportsmanship,
violence, cheating, drug use, racism, sexism, and gender
equity.
* Includes essays by psychologists, sociologists, coaches, and
sports writers.
* Gives the reader an understanding of the moral significance of
sport, and how sports affect society.
Notes on Contributors ix
Foreword by Dean Smith xv
Preface xvi
Acknowledgments xviii
Introduction - The Moral Significance of Sport 1
Jan Boxill
Part I: Sport and Education
1. Sports, Relativism, and Moral Education 16
Robert L. Simon
2. Why Everyone Deserves a Sporting Chance: Education, Justice, and School Sports 29
Janice Moulton
3. Moral Development and Sport: Character and Cognitive Developmentalism Contrasted 40
Carwyn Jones and Michael McNamee
4. Philosopher in the Playground: Notes on the Meaning of Sport 53
Peter Heinegg
5. Foul Play: Sports Metaphors as Public Doublespeak 56
Francine Hardaway
Part II: Sport and Sportsmanship
6. Sportsmanship as a Moral Category 63
James W. Keating
7. Three Approaches Toward an Understanding of Sportsmanship 72
Peter J. Arnold
8. Deception, Sportsmanship, and Ethics 81
Kathleen M. Pearson
9. On Sportsmanship and "Running up the Score" 84
Nicholas Dixon
10. Sportmanship and Blowouts: Baseball and Beyond 95
Randolph M. Feezell
Part III: Sport and Competition
11. The Ethics of Competition 107
Jan Boxill
12. On Winning and Athletic Superiority 116
Nicholas Dixon
13. In Defense of Winning 130
R. Scott Kretchmar
14. Winding Down, Looking Ahead 136
Dean Smith
15. Personal Best 144
W. M. Brown
16. Fair Play as Respect for the Game 153
Robert Butcher and Angela Schneider
Part IV: Sport and Drugs
17. Good Competition and Drug-Enhanced Performance 175
Robert L. Simon
18. Enhancing Performance in Sports: What is Morally Permissible? 182
Laura Morgan
19. Sports and Drugs: Are Current Bans Justified? 189
Michael Lavin
Part V: Sport and Violence
20. What is Sports Violence? 199
Michael Smith
21. Values and Violence in Sports Today: The Moral Reasoning Athletes Use in Their Games and in their Lives 217
Brenda Jo Bredemeier, David L. Shields, Jack C. Horn
22. Violence and Sports
Robert E. Leach
Part VI: Sport and Gender
23. Sex Equality in Sports 225
Jane English
24. Human Equality in Sports 230
Peter S. Wenz
25. Gender Equity and Inequity in Athletics 240
Robert L. Simon.
26. Title IX and Gender Equity 254
Jan Boxill
27. Why Women do Better than Men in College Basketball, or "What is Collegiate Sport for, Anyway?" 262
Nicholas Hunt-Bull
28. Women, Self-Possession, and Sport 267
Catharine MacKinnon
29. Stronger Women 273
Mariah Burton Nelson
30, The Sports Closet 289
Liz Galst
Part VII: Sport and Racial Issues
31. Racial Differences in Sports: What's Ethics Got To Do With It? 297
Albert Mosely
32. Race and College Sport: A Long Way to Go 304
Richard E. Lapchick
33. Sport and Stereotype: From Role Model to Muhammad Ali 310
Mike Marqusee
Part VIII: Sport and Role Models
34. Do Celebrated Athletes have Special Responsibilities to be Good Role Models? An Imagined Dialog between Charles Barkley and Karl Malone 333
Christopher Wellman
35. Get the Message? 337
Rick Reilly
Index 339
Foreword by Dean Smith xv
Preface xvi
Acknowledgments xviii
Introduction - The Moral Significance of Sport 1
Jan Boxill
Part I: Sport and Education
1. Sports, Relativism, and Moral Education 16
Robert L. Simon
2. Why Everyone Deserves a Sporting Chance: Education, Justice, and School Sports 29
Janice Moulton
3. Moral Development and Sport: Character and Cognitive Developmentalism Contrasted 40
Carwyn Jones and Michael McNamee
4. Philosopher in the Playground: Notes on the Meaning of Sport 53
Peter Heinegg
5. Foul Play: Sports Metaphors as Public Doublespeak 56
Francine Hardaway
Part II: Sport and Sportsmanship
6. Sportsmanship as a Moral Category 63
James W. Keating
7. Three Approaches Toward an Understanding of Sportsmanship 72
Peter J. Arnold
8. Deception, Sportsmanship, and Ethics 81
Kathleen M. Pearson
9. On Sportsmanship and "Running up the Score" 84
Nicholas Dixon
10. Sportmanship and Blowouts: Baseball and Beyond 95
Randolph M. Feezell
Part III: Sport and Competition
11. The Ethics of Competition 107
Jan Boxill
12. On Winning and Athletic Superiority 116
Nicholas Dixon
13. In Defense of Winning 130
R. Scott Kretchmar
14. Winding Down, Looking Ahead 136
Dean Smith
15. Personal Best 144
W. M. Brown
16. Fair Play as Respect for the Game 153
Robert Butcher and Angela Schneider
Part IV: Sport and Drugs
17. Good Competition and Drug-Enhanced Performance 175
Robert L. Simon
18. Enhancing Performance in Sports: What is Morally Permissible? 182
Laura Morgan
19. Sports and Drugs: Are Current Bans Justified? 189
Michael Lavin
Part V: Sport and Violence
20. What is Sports Violence? 199
Michael Smith
21. Values and Violence in Sports Today: The Moral Reasoning Athletes Use in Their Games and in their Lives 217
Brenda Jo Bredemeier, David L. Shields, Jack C. Horn
22. Violence and Sports
Robert E. Leach
Part VI: Sport and Gender
23. Sex Equality in Sports 225
Jane English
24. Human Equality in Sports 230
Peter S. Wenz
25. Gender Equity and Inequity in Athletics 240
Robert L. Simon.
26. Title IX and Gender Equity 254
Jan Boxill
27. Why Women do Better than Men in College Basketball, or "What is Collegiate Sport for, Anyway?" 262
Nicholas Hunt-Bull
28. Women, Self-Possession, and Sport 267
Catharine MacKinnon
29. Stronger Women 273
Mariah Burton Nelson
30, The Sports Closet 289
Liz Galst
Part VII: Sport and Racial Issues
31. Racial Differences in Sports: What's Ethics Got To Do With It? 297
Albert Mosely
32. Race and College Sport: A Long Way to Go 304
Richard E. Lapchick
33. Sport and Stereotype: From Role Model to Muhammad Ali 310
Mike Marqusee
Part VIII: Sport and Role Models
34. Do Celebrated Athletes have Special Responsibilities to be Good Role Models? An Imagined Dialog between Charles Barkley and Karl Malone 333
Christopher Wellman
35. Get the Message? 337
Rick Reilly
Index 339
'Sports Ethics is a cleverly compiled anthology that
clearly addresses the main issues facing sport today. Previously
published classical arguments by highly respected sport
philosophers are augmented by ten new articles written specifically
for this anthology. This is topical, well organized and insightful
- an excellent addition to the literature.' John M.
Charles, The College of William and Mary
'The selections in this volume give a powerful statement
of the common practices in sport which negate the values that sport
is supposed to instill: justice, respect, responsibility, and
honesty. In addition, Dean Smith's foreword offers a thoughtful,
pragmatic point of view which often is lost in theoretical
work.' Sharon Kay Stoll, University of Idaho
clearly addresses the main issues facing sport today. Previously
published classical arguments by highly respected sport
philosophers are augmented by ten new articles written specifically
for this anthology. This is topical, well organized and insightful
- an excellent addition to the literature.' John M.
Charles, The College of William and Mary
'The selections in this volume give a powerful statement
of the common practices in sport which negate the values that sport
is supposed to instill: justice, respect, responsibility, and
honesty. In addition, Dean Smith's foreword offers a thoughtful,
pragmatic point of view which often is lost in theoretical
work.' Sharon Kay Stoll, University of Idaho
Jan Boxill is Associate Chair and Lecturer at the University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill. She is author of Issues in Racism and Sexism (2000).